Really well done breakfast bagel sandwich. The bagels are a good size for sure. I just had eggs and cheese on mine but it was still delightful. Coffee was good too.

small space, limited seating. I've gone several times and they are always out of something. the last time I went their espresso machine was broken so they couldn't make coffee. the bagel sandwiches I've ordered are very good and the employees are nice.

Good chow. Great bagels. Very flavorful. They don't scrimp on ingredients! Would definitely go again.

Stopped by on a Monday morning around 10:30am as this sounded like a great place to get a quick breakfast before the journey back to Milwaukee, Wisconsin. It was so much busier than I anticipated for the time of day. As I waited to reach the counter to place an order, I saw others orders being taken to tables. It all looked and smelled incredible. Sadly, there was a problem. The menu is posted behind the counter, like how it is at Panera or fast food restaurant, is approximately 15-30 ft away, depending on where you are standing....in size 14 point font. Maybe it was 16 point, not sure because I couldn't read it. I couldn't even read it when I got up to the counter. Now, my eye doctor did say I might need readers soon, but this was a challenge for my distance vision and I just changed my contacts. Once I realized I couldn't read the menu, I looked up the website to read it from my phone. There were only very specific sandwiches listed, which was not helpful as it clearly did not reflect the menu posted. Everyone around me must have known the menu by heart and had no issues ordering. The line went quickly, Too quickly for me to even ask someone else how the whole operation works. Then I had to become *that* customer, the one who has to asks several questions and hold up the line because they are clueless. I noticed customer after customer going through the order line beside me and I just started panicking, so I spit out "turkey and cheddar," then the dreaded question: on which bagel? I could barley make out the signs posted on the bins with the bagels, and Asiago it was. Because I'm from Wisconsin and I like cheese. Tables are fairly close together, so not an intimate setting and not a place for personal talk. I felt far too involved in conversation taking place at the table beside me. It took a few minutes before the bagel arrived. It was massive, it was delicious, it was much better than I anticipated! There is a reason this is a popular spot. Highly recommend as long as you are not short on time (if ordering in person), but have an idea of what you want ahead of time. Apparently it's a BYOB - build your own bagel [sandwich] - but I'm not really even sure what is all offered. Hence -1 star. Also, I apologize to everyone behind me on that Monday morning.

Incredible menu with every option of bagel you could ask for. Delicious combos. Generous portions.

I wish we had Third Street Bagel where I live so I can try more bagels. They had so many options which is overwhelmingly exciting but terrifying because which sandwich do you choose! This was my first meal of the day before going on hikes so I chose the Middle Eastern bagel. This included fresh hummus, tomato, cucumber, and sprouts on a garlic bagel. Refreshing yet divine!

I've been here a couple of times. I like that you can order breakfast all day and that there are vegetarian options. The bagels have always been fresh, but if you go for lunch they are always running low or out of certain varieties. The inside was recently renovated, and it looks very nice and modern. They definitely need to hire more people